I take a supplement containing a "proprietary formula" which lists many ingredients. Can ConsumerLab test the contents so I'll know the amounts of each ingredient?
ConsumerLab.com has long cautioned against purchasing supplements with proprietary formulas
and typically does not test them. We may, however, check listed amounts of other key, individually listed ingredients in the same supplement. In some cases, we have found high levels of contaminants which, we suspect, originated from ingredients in a proprietary formula.
The major problem with "proprietary formulas," as well as with proprietary "blends" and "complexes," is that they permit manufacturers to withhold important information about what's really in a product. The company only has to list the total amount of formula, not the amount of each ingredient
in the formula. The formula's ingredients only have to be listed in weight order, i.e., based on their relative contribution to the weight of the formula. Furthermore, the formula may change over time without you necessarily knowing.
Proprietary formulas are often developed around an expensive ingredient, like CoQ10
, because this allows a company to use less of the expensive ingredient, creating a formula in which the expensive ingredient is just a small part of the formula. We have seen this with ingredients such as chondroitin in joint supplements
, and SAMe
. We also see proprietary formulas marketed for uses such as cognitive enhancement
, nerve pain
, or weight loss
where a company may try to impress the consumer with a laundry list of ingredients having only shreds of evidence relating to the intended use. In most cases, the formulas themselves have not been clinically tested.
Also see these related CL Answers:
What is Skinny Fiber and does it really work? I see that glucomannan is a key ingredient. What is that? >>
Does Procera AVH really improve memory and mood? >>
Do any supplements help with nerve pain, like sciatica or diabetic neuropathy? >>
I find labels of some supplement bottles misleading. For example, an L-theanine label says 200 mg on the front but the back says each pill contains just 100 mg, noting that a serving is 2 capsules. Is this legal? >>
This CL Answer initially posted on 1/16/2016.
Last updated 8/2/2017.