About ConsumerLab.com


Counterfeit Water Filters

Answer:

Counterfeit Water Filters Are a Problem

To improve water that is contaminated or unpleasant to drink, water filters (such as those in refrigerators, water filter pitchers, and under the sink filters) rely on proper design, components, and assembly to perform effectively. Counterfeit water filters have been sold online and may not provide the benefits of genuine water filters.

In May 2023, U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP) discovered and seized 3,940 counterfeit water filters bearing unauthorized National Sanitation Foundation (NSF) certification logos, a third-party certification that indicates that a product meets certain filtration standards. When tested, the counterfeit filters failed to remove lead and other chemicals from the water.

According to partial test results published by an industry group (the Association of Home Appliance Manufacturers) in 2018, many counterfeit refrigerator water filters purchased through popular websites failed to adequately remove lead and live cysts from household water, and some introduced harmful compounds into the water. The products were counterfeit versions of filters from LG, Electrolux, Samsung, Whirlpool, GE Appliances, and Sub-Zero filters.

Also be aware that even genuine water filters can be better than others for filtering certain impurities from water. See ConsumerLab’s tests and reviews of popular water filter pitchers.

Where to Buy Genuine Water Filters Online

It is often difficult to know if an online seller, such as a website, or a seller on Amazon.com, Walmart.com, or other online marketplace, is authorized by the brand to distribute its products. To help, we’ve created the table below showing the registered brand names, store names, and authorized resellers of each brand, as confirmed by us with each brand.

To avoid fake and potentially ineffective or dangerous water filters, keep these tips in mind:

  • Shop directly from the brand’s website. This is the best way to avoid purchasing counterfeit products.
  • Shop from distributors and retailers authorized by the brand. These are often listed on the brand’s website on a “Where to Buy” page.
  • On retail websites like Amazon.com and Walmart.com, shop only from “approved sellers.”
  • Examine the listing. Check the product and seller’s reviews and ratings. Compare the brand’s own description, images, and specifications with the listing. Be wary of any unusually low prices or deals.

Authorized Online Sellers of Water Filters – By Brand

Brand
Authorized Online E-tailers and Resellers
Aquagear
—Own website
— Amazon.comα: Sold by "Aquagear" and "Amazon LLC"
Aquasana
—Own website
— Amazon.comα†: Sold on “Aquasana” store by “Aquasana.” 
— Walmart.com: Sold by "Walmart.com"
— Other sites: HomeDepot.com, Lowes.com
Berkey
— Own website
— Amazon.com: Sold on “Berkey” store by “The Brky Guy,” “Safecastle,” “BrandRocket,” “Discount Filter Store,” and “9G Health Foods
— Other sites: Bigberkeywaterfilters.com, Berkeycleanwater.com, Myberkey.com, more**
— List of unauthorized sellers on own website.
Brita
— Own website
— Amazon.comα†: Sold on “Brita” store.
— Walmart.com: Sold by “Walmart.com”
— Other sites: Target.com
Electrolux
— Amazon.comα
— Sold on Walmart.com
— Other sites: AllFilters.com, DiscountFilters.com, FiltersFast.com, Frigidaire.com, HomeDepot.com
Frigidaire
— Own website
— Amazon.comα
— Sold on Walmart.com
— Other sites: FiltersFast.com, HomeDepot.com, Lowes.com
— Note: AllFilters.com and DiscountFilters.com are not authorized sellers.
GE Appliances
— Own website
— Sold on Amazon.com
— Sold on Walmart.com
— Other sites: HomeDepot.com, Lowes.com
— Note: DiscountFilters.com and FiltersFast.com are not authorized sellers.
Kirkland
— Own website
— Does not sell on Amazon.com or Walmart.com.
KitchenAid
— Own website
— Amazon.comα
— Walmart.com: Sold by “Walmart.com”
— Other sites: everydropwater.com
— Note: DiscountFilters.com and FiltersFast.com are not authorized sellers.
LG
— Own website
— Amazon.comα†: Sold on “LG” store.
— Sold on Walmart.com?
— Other sites: BestBuy.com, DeyDistributing.com, Encompass.com, HomeDepot.com, Lowes.com, Marcone.com, Reliableparts.com, SundbergAmerica.com, Tribles.com, VVApplianceParts.com
— Note: DiscountFilters.com and FiltersFast.com are not authorized sellers.
LifeStraw
— Own website
— Amazon.comα†: Sold on “LifeStraw” store.
— Walmart.com: Sold by “Walmart.com” or “Lifestraw”
— Other sites: BassProShop.com, CrateAndBarrel.com, Grainger.com, REI.com, Scheels.com, Target.com
ProOne
— Own website
— Amazon.com: Sold by “ProOne Water Filters Direct“ and on “ProOne Water Filters” store.
—  Sold on Walmart.com?
— Other sites?
PUR
— Own website
— Amazon.comα: Sold on “PUR” store.
— Walmart.com: Sold by “Walmart”
— Other sites: AceHardware.com, CVS.com, FredMeyer.com, HomeDepot.com, Lowes.com, Meijer.com, Menards.com, RiteAid.com, Target.com, Walgreens.com
Samsung
— Own website
— Amazon.comα
— Sold on Walmart.com
— Other sites**
— Note: DiscountFilters.com and FiltersFast.com are not authorized sellers.
Sub-Zero
— Own website
— Does not sell on Amazon.com or Walmart.com.
ZeroWater
— Own website
— Amazon.comα: Sold on “ZeroWater” store.
— Walmart.com: Sold by “Walmart”
— Other sites**: FiltersFast.com
α Also "sold by" Amazon on Amazon.com
**See brand's website for full list of authorized resellers.
? - Company has not responded to ConsumerLab.com as to how the company sells on Amazon.com or Walmart.com.
† Links to the indicated site are affiliate links and may generate a commission paid to ConsumerLab.com if you buy products from that site. Affiliate links are not used in Product Reviews on ConsumerLab.com, as CL does not otherwise derive revenue from the sale of products that it reviews.

Discount & Replacement Water Filter Sites

Some websites sell water filters from popular brands at discounted prices, or sell lower-cost replacement filters from their own or other brands. However, we learned that brands may or may not authorize these sites to sell their products. Here is what we’ve heard from the sites and from brands sold on them:

DiscountFilters.com — Told us “Any brands on our site, we have been authorized to sell” but this does not appear to be correct.

  • Brands saying the site is an authorized seller: Electrolux
  • Brands saying the site is not an authorized seller: Frigidaire, GE, LG, KitchenAid, and Samsung
  • Brands not yet responding: Whirlpool

FiltersFast.com — Claims to be the “the top filtration provider online in the United States.” Sells its own FiltersFast.com brand of products and other brands.

  • Brands saying the site is an authorized seller: Electrolux, Frigidaire, and ZeroWater
  • Brands saying the site is not an authorized seller: GE, LG, KitchenAid, and Samsung (In fact, prices may be higher for these brands on FiltersFast than on the brand's own site or from its authorized sellers.)
  • Brands not yet responding: Brita, PUR, Sub-Zero

AllFilters.com — Claims to have “the lowest price on filters every day” and a “one-stop shop for all…filtration needs.”

  • Brands saying the site is an authorized seller: Electrolux
  • Brands saying the site is not an authorized seller: Frigidaire
  • Brands that cannot yet confirm: LG and Samsung

Is Your Water Filter Counterfeit?

Any of the following suggests a counterfeit filter:

  • A missing certification mark on the packaging (if the product is known to be certified by a third party). If the product has an NSF certification, confirm it on NSF's website. 
  • Incorrect symbols or misspellings on the packaging.
  • A lighter weight to the filter than expected. Counterfeit water filters tend to weigh less than real filters.

What to Do if You Receive a Counterfeit Water Filter

If you suspect that a product you received may be counterfeit, don’t use it. If you purchased the filter from Amazon, request a refund or exchange. (Note that third-party sellers may have different return policies than those sold and shipped by Amazon, and some may have a no return policy, so be sure to check return and refund policies before buying.) Also consider posting a comment about the issue further down on this page and consider reporting a fraudulent product on the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) website.

Join today to unlock all member benefits including full access to all CL Answers and over 1,400 reviews.

Join Now

Join now at www.consumerlab.com/join/

16 Comments

mary21218
November 28, 2024

I'm seeking literature for under sink filters. Have you tested them?

ConsumerLab.com
December 04, 2024

We have not evaluated under-sink filters, but our article on PFAS provides insights into their efficacy in removing PFAS based on testing conducted by other researchers: https://www.consumerlab.com/answers/toxic-pfas-chemicals-in-dental-floss/pfas-dental-floss/#effectiveness-of-point-of-use-water-filters

MizzF
January 25, 2025

I have been using a Multipure undersink filter for years. I do auto renew and have a new filter sent to me every 8 months.

MJ18860
February 27, 2024

Thank you for this! I've been buying filters for my refrigerator regularly on Amazon and now I know what to look for.

ConsumerLab.com
February 27, 2024

Glad to help!

Clark18440
December 10, 2023

When we bought our house it came with a Maytag refrigerator. I found Maxblue filters that were very effective at removing the taste of chlorine from the water.
We got an LG refrigerator when the Maytag quit working and the water from the LG has a strong chlorine taste. Any hints where we might find a Maxblue filter for our LG refrigerator model LMWS27626S/00?

Jada
January 30, 2024

I have the same problem with my LG refrigerator filter not filtering out chlorine, taste, or smell.

Researcher
December 09, 2023

I am so thankful for CL. I purchase filters for my Brita pitcher on Amazon and try to get the cheapest brand, so now am more educated on what to look for. Who knows what and if my water is purified.

Sally18437
December 13, 2023

I recently bought a box of a dozen filters at Costco and when I got them home, I realized they weren't Brita but Kirkland. I used them anyway because I had opened the box, but I'm not confident they do the job. (However, they do shed less grit than the Brita brand used to do.) Anyone got info on Kirkland?

ConsumerLab.com
December 13, 2023

Hi Sally - We tested Kirkland Water Filter Pitchers with Kirkland brand water filter cartridges this year. Results are in our Water Filter Pitchers Review. We do not know, however, how well a Kirkland filter performs in a Brita pitcher, as that would depend on proper fit.

Lawrence18435
December 08, 2023

I purchased filters distributed by Target to fit traditional Brita pitchers, but the "origin" was United Kingdom. They were much less expensive and supposedly reduced copper, mercury, benzine, cadmium, zinc, and limescale. It would be helpful to know if Consumer Labs would approve the validity.

Pat18428
December 03, 2023

I bought a GE filter for my refrigerator from Amazon. It did not turn off the replace water filter notification. I called GE, and they sent me a new filter. I won't buy them from Amazon again because I think it was counterfeit. I have no financial interest in GE or Amazon.

Michael18630
February 05, 2024

For my Kenmore refrigerators, I must manually reset the replace filter notification by pushing a button several times. I never had a fridge that automatically detected a filter replacement.

Susan18421
December 01, 2023

With the overwhelming choices for every items, I rely on ConsumerLab for accurate information before purchasing.
Kudos to this consumer-friendly organization.

ConsumerLab.com
December 04, 2023

Glad to be of help!

ann18420
December 01, 2023

Good advice for spotting counterfeits. Just because it's on Amazon doesn't mean the seller's product has been vetted.

Join the conversation

(0/2500)