About ConsumerLab.com


Spirulina Powder and Pills

Answer:

Concern has been raised by the fact that BMAA, a neurotoxic compound, can be produced by organisms related to spirulina -- a common ingredient in dietary supplements, including "green" powders and drinks. Commonly referred to as a blue-green algae, spirulina is actually a type of cyanobacteria (formerly called blue-green algae) and many cyanobacteria can produce BMAA. However, small studies suggest that dietary supplements with spirulina are generally safe. Concerns remain, however, about other blue-green algae, particularly Aph. flos-aquae.

Another concern with supplements made from cyanobacteria is contamination with microcystin toxin — a liver toxin, which appears to be common in A. flos-aquae supplements but tends not to occur in significant amounts in spirulina supplements.

Get the details, and see the results of our tests of powders and pills containing spirulina (three of which failed our tests), in the Greens and Whole Foods Powders and Pills Review >>

Join today to unlock all member benefits including full access to all CL Answers and over 1,400 reviews.

Join Now

Join now at www.consumerlab.com/join/

19 Comments

Taygete
August 12, 2023

Also threw up violently from chlorella, and as I took it each day it got worse than the day before…once I figured out the connection decided to never take it again. I gave the very expensive bottle to a friend who was sure he would not have the same issue because he had been taking it for awhile, and he took it without any problems.

maria19643
June 07, 2024

I too had the same issue. I called the company to ask if other consumers had the same reaction and they said no, but can be a possibility so to take 1 pill and then work my way up. After taking just 1 pill the same thing happened violently vomiting. I tried to find any information about why that would be the case and couldn't find any, so I threw the very expensive pills away.

Michael6150
January 18, 2022

The full page review doesn’t show BMAA levels…just heavy metals.

ConsumerLab.com
January 18, 2022

None of the products listed A. flos-aquae as an ingredient, so BMAA testing was no performed. However, we found lead contamination in two products that contained spirulina, as well as issues with pill formulations.

Brett6148
March 23, 2019

I would stay as far away as possible. As a former consumer, I have my own concerns, and yet it would be foolish to be an alarmist over specious facts, so we should just ignore late-breaking research because it seems half baked?... I think not. Just remember that lead and asbestos, as well as tobacco and a littany of products and drugs, were also deemed "safe".

But as the old adage goes, "better safe than sorry":https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4130116/.

Mark6149
February 05, 2020

That bit of research you cited gives Spirulina a clean bill of health.

Doug6145
January 04, 2018

I just wanted to add a few more interesting articles about Spirulina and the potential for neurotoxin/bmaa contamination.

http://www.science20.com/australian_researchers_discover_potential_blue_green_algae_cause_treatment_of_motor_neuron_disease_mnd_als-121193

http://www.equineherbalist.ie/blog/82-spirulina-dangers.html

JARKKO6146
October 07, 2018

Both of those 2 articles were written several years ago and may contain outdated information.
When you send links, it would be nice if you included some kind of description about the links, for example year published and written by who, scientist or consumer.

ConsumerLab.com
January 02, 2018

Thanks for posting that article, Doug. Oddly, although that study found no contamination issues, it does not seem to include lead among the tested metals. We have found lead contamination in some Spirulina-containing "greens" supplements, as noted in our Greens/Whole Food Supplements Review at https://www.consumerlab.com/reviews/greens-whole-foods-powders-supplements/greens/. However, its possible that lead was from another ingredient.

As noted in our Answer above, Spirulina products have generally been found to be safe in small studies, but we'll keep your suggestion in mind.

Doug6143
January 02, 2018

Here is a Heavy metal analysis in 25 different commercial Spirulina products for human consumption. Unfortunately, this not include cyanobacteria/BMAA testing.

http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1319562X13000430

marina6140
February 15, 2016

Yes well I have grave doubts about Chlorella - projectle vomiting is not a 'detox' reaction in my view- rather a toxic one!

Carolyn6132
February 14, 2016

A lot of Spirulina is produced on the Big Island of Hawaii...and the ponds are right next to the airport. For me, that raises questions about possible contamination with toxic compounds.

ConsumerLab.com
February 19, 2016

Hi Carolyn - As contamination is a known issue with ingredients derived from algae, ConsumerLab.com tests products containing Spirulina for contamination with arsenic, cadmium, lead, mercury and pesticides. You can see results for products we've tested in the Greens Review: https://www.consumerlab.com/reviews/greens-whole-foods-powders-supplements/greens/#results
and find more information about potential contamination in the Concerns and Cautions section of the review: https://www.consumerlab.com/reviews/greens-whole-foods-powders-supplements/greens/#bmaa

JARKKO6135
February 19, 2018

What makes you think an airport is a problem? I have never heard humans to get any breathing problems by living near airport. It is the noise that is the problem.

Elio6136
May 29, 2018

Groundwater contamination from fuel and solvents is not uncommon near airports. That would be my primary concern.

JARKKO6137
October 07, 2018

Good point, for example firefighting foams may contaminate groundwater near airports.

Daniela6131
February 14, 2016

What about Chlorella? Is it same concern as Spirulina?

Abby6128
February 14, 2016

Quite a few years ago I had an adverse reaction to Sun Chlorella. About an hour after ingestion I began vomiting violently every few minutes. My blood pressure shot up. I thought I might be having a heart attack and went to the emergency room. After questioning I admitted to eating some leftover brussel sprouts but completely forgot to mention the Chlorella.
I wasn't having a heart attack but the brussel sprouts went into my medical record. Ha ha.
I didn't make the connection until a few weeks later when I again ingested the Sun Chlorella supplement. Just a few minutes later I began vomiting violently. I was driving at the time, and pulled into a parking lot, and spent the next hour vomiting into a garbage bag. Eventually a police car pulled in nearby and observed me for about 20 minutes and then left.
Finally I made the connection, and have studiously avoided Sun Chlorella.
I should note that I've taken both spirulina and blue green algae supplements for years with no problems.
Side note, when I take blue green algae, which is not often, my dreams at night become brighter.

ConsumerLab.com
February 21, 2016

Hi Abby - Thank you for letting us know about your experience with this product. Other gastrointestinal side effects have been reported with Chlorella supplementation, which is discussed in the "Concerns and Cautions" section of the Greens and Whole Foods Powders and Pills Review: https://www.consumerlab.com/reviews/greens-whole-foods-powders-supplements/greens/#concerns

Join the conversation

(0/2500)