MENU
ConsumerLab.com Answers

Question:
Does Prevagen really improve memory?

Answer:
According to the company's website, people who use people Prevagen (Quincy Bioscience) can "experience improved memory, a sharper mind, and clearer thinking. However, a review of the evidence indicates that these effects are not well substantiated. In addition, the FDA has warned Quincy Bioscience in the past against claiming Prevagen could treat conditions such as head injuries and Alzheimer's disease and for failing to report adverse reactions. The FDA has also claimed that the key ingredient, apoaequorin, a synthetic protein, is not an acceptable ingredient in a dietary supplement.  

For a more detailed look at the evidence, safety, ingredients, and history of Prevagen, see the full answer >> 

See ConsumerLab.com's Encyclopedia of Natural Products article about Enhancing Memory and Mental Function.


What is PQQ? Does it help with aging and memory? Is it similar to CoQ10? >>

Can curcumin help prevent or improve symptoms of Alzheimer's disease? >>

Do magnesium supplements, like Magtein, help memory or protect against Alzheimer's disease? >>

Also see these related CL Answers:

Does Procera AVH really improve memory and mood? >>

Do any supplements really help with brain function, like memory and cognition? >>

Do magnesium supplements, like Magtein, help memory or protect against Alzheimer's disease? >>

What is PQQ? Does it help with aging and memory? Is it similar to CoQ10?  >>

Can fisetin, also called Cognisetin and Novusetin, really improve memory? >>

Can curcumin help prevent or improve symptoms of Alzheimer's disease? >>

What is Brain Bright and can it really improve memory or cognition? >>

Do either phosphatidylserine or phosphatidylcholine help with memory and cognition? How are these supplements different? >>



See other recent and popular questions >>
Comments
Add Comment

margaret16338   January 5, 2018
I use it now and again. I think it works and I believe that a neighbor of mine had extremely good results although he did die of Alzheimer's at thew age of 94. Try it before you dis it.

Don15666   October 15, 2017
But their carefully constructed infomercials seem soooooo convincing! LOL.

Dennis15546   September 17, 2017
I participated in a clinical trial for this product. it lasted 6 months. what I had were vivid dreams. no clearer mind, no better memory. at the end of the study I was asked by the company if I wanted to purchase the product at a reduced cost. the reduction amounted to $5.00 less than priced online. no thank you. it wasn't that good. ga

Douglas15527   September 13, 2017
It's too early to say but is looking as though this could be the greatest biomedical scam in history, with the owners of Prevagen in a position to make many hundreds of millions of dollars in relationship to an initial stock offering. To say that the evidence is unimpressive is a severe understatement, as there really is no true evidence of efficacy, and even more, plenty of reason to be suspicious that the compound as it has been described could have ANY mechanistic impact on short-term memory or for that matter, even on neuronal function, although there is still much to learn on that question.

First of all, as others have pointed out, proteins are typically broken down G.I. tract, and even if they are not, they do not cross the blood brain barrier unless chaperoned in special ways by lipids or immune cells or blood brain barrier endothelial cells. There is no evidence for that either (transit across the blood brain barrier), and to make matters worse, there is no evidence that its putative mechanism, namely the rectification some kind of calcium channel dysfunction has any role in age-related short-term memory inefficiencies, or that blocking calcium channels would have any impact on patients with amnestic conditions – and indeed as others have pointed out, blocking calcium channels in a haphazard fashion might even be dangerous and could even lead to amnestic conditions, although excessive calcium channel activity can lead to programmed cell death.

In other words there is every reason to think that this is a billion-dollar scam unprecedented in the history of nutraceuticals. It's in a position to give every other responsible nutraceutical manufacturer a black eye by implication. As usual, the FDA's response is underwhelming when dealing with either pharmaceutical or nutraceutical firms that may be bad actors.

HR15504   September 13, 2017
I can only take Extra Strength Prevagen every other day as it gives me a headache taken daily.
Strontium is good for bones. since stopping calcium, I have taken Strontium. I can tell, by my better than ever fingernails, that it's working!

ConsumerLab.com   September 13, 2017
Thanks for sharing this HR. You can read more about strontium in our Encyclopedia article: https://www.consumerlab.com/tnp.asp?chunkiid=111809 and in this CL Answer: https://www.consumerlab.com/answers/_/osteoporosis/

Susan 15397   August 16, 2017
After finding no improvement with the regular strength Prevagen, we bought the Extra Strength Prevagen when it was introduced. Among three unrelated people, no one noticed an improvement in memory. We did note a big loss of money on a product that we feel that the FTC should nvestigate. We feel it is more of a scam.

Robert11354   October 19, 2016
The problem is excess calcium. "Get your calcium" is wrong clinically 90% of the time based on over 3,000 HTMA results. Calcium should never be taken without a HTMA that confirms it is needed. Taking calcium to "prevent osteoporosis" is ineffective and proven to increases the risk of Cardiac events 22-30% in multiple studies, stroke 15-20%, kidney and gall stones, Macular degeneration, and is proven to shrink the brain and destroy the working memory cell function. "Get your calcium" is a major cause of dementia, proven.
Adequate trace mineral supplementation is required to prevent and treat and reverse osteoporosis. It is not a calcium deficiency, it is mineral deficiency always. In less than 10% of cases, calcium is also needed.
Robert Thompson, M.D. Co-author, The Calcium Lie 2

Jeanne15421   August 20, 2017
I agree completely Dr. Thompson. Well said.

Michael8594   April 3, 2016
I have taken this product on and off for over a year. I notice positive effects the most pronounced being, remembering my dreams. Before taking the product I had not recalled my dreams for years. I now recall them almost nightly. BTW a supplement does not have to reach the brain to have a positive effect. With everything they are learning about the Microbiome and how food and supplements effect the gut bacteria and how that bacteria effects our health. I to have no finical interest in this product other than wishing it cost less.

Helen15519   September 13, 2017
Whether you remembering your dreams or not depends on issues different than recall of encoded items in memory. Do a search, and you will see the relevant variables.

Marc8423   February 5, 2016
I give talks to health care professionals all over the US (nutritional effects on development in infants). It's because of reviews like this that I routinely recommend Consumerlab.com to anyone who takes dietary supplements and wants to know about their safety and efficacy, and I can cite examples (like this) where your thorough review of the evidence provides what one needs to know before using a dietary supplement.

Thank you,

Marc Masor, Ph.D.

Louis8034   November 5, 2015
I have taken the product and have some improvement in all areas, and experienced none of the alleged side affects. It is to expensive to continue on a regular basis.

Melanie8597   April 3, 2016
I also have taken Prevagen several years ago for about 6 months. I also noticed improvements but I stopped taking it because there was no information regarding the safety of the product at that time. I would really like to take it again except it is to expensive.

HR15505   September 13, 2017
I have bought it on Ebay,new and not expired, for about half price.

Robert6896   August 9, 2015
Aequorin is a protein and will be hydrolyzed in the stomach. So negligible amount of intact protein will be absorbed into the body from the GI tract. Even if the protein was administered by injection it is unlikely that it could cross the blood-brain-barrier. If by any remote chance the protein does make it into brain cells, it could be neurotoxic by virtue of chelating calcium ions which are essential to cell function.
Robert C. Speth, Ph.D. I have no financial interest in this or a competing product

Nathaniel668   April 15, 2015
Thanks for your useful info on this "memory aid." I was almost taken in by their commercials... until I though to look it up on your site. When I saw that there were adverse effects by a number of people, and that all the "studies" weren't 'blinded' or in peer reviewed journals, I felt I had the information I needed to decide not to part with a substantial amount of money for what I judged to be a dubious supplement.

don6946   September 13, 2015
Donald: My focus and recall {ESP.} names have gotten worse this last year. I am wondering if any supplements, vitamins or anything can help with memory? Would appreciate any advise or suggestions!!


violet11558   January 2, 2017
I have taken Prevagen since 2006. It works great. It took around 2 months for me to notice a difference in memory. I noticed that I could remember people's names, dates and etc.....When my memory got better I quit taking it until I noticed a decline again, and started taking it again. I don't have to take it all the time anymore, I see no need to continue taking a supplement once your problem has been reversed, I think that may be why people have problems with supplements, they get too much over a period of time. I would recommend Prevagen to anyone that is having problems remembering daily activities.

Chris11593   January 11, 2017
Without actual studies to review, this experience can easily be explained by the placebo effect.

Linda525   February 8, 2015
Thank you So Much Consumer Lab for all the studies you do to keep us safe from products like this!!!

ConsumerLab.com   February 9, 2015
Thank you for your kind words, Linda!

Carol8095   November 23, 2015
I agree with Linda. I should have checked Consumer Lab before I was taken in and bought the Prevagen last week. Now I will return it. I have heard so much about this product on the radio station I listen to.
Carol Thompson

Bob11425   November 27, 2016
You beat me to it, Linda! Since Mom died of degenerative brain disease that started relatively young as Alzheimer's, I have to fight the impulse to buy anything promoted for brain health. Consumer Labs, you just paid for yourself. Again.

Talbot11582   January 8, 2017
I am always leery about any product promoted with slick, overproduced advertising by a 3rd party firm. That always implies huge built-in cost of the product to pay for ad production costs plus air time.

Additionally, another red flag arises when the "tests" are paid for by the manufacturer and not peer-reviewed or published outside of their own promotion--a clear conflict of interest. A final strike is when the FDA has issued a sanction letter to the company in question.

John16268   December 7, 2017
I agree Linda525. I have subscribed to Consumer Labs for 6 years. I am an R.N. with 25 years of ER experience. I often do research on Consumer Labs for friends who are drawn in by slick commercials for nutritional supplements. My appreciation to Consumer Labs for their work.

This CL Answer initially posted on 2/7/2015. Last updated 10/14/2017.

Add Comment...

Share your thoughts and comments about this topic in the space below. Please abide by the following rules:
  • If you make a statement of fact, such as whether a type of treatment does or does not work, state your basis -- such as personal experience or a published study.
  • If you make a positive or negative comment about a product, note whether or not you have a financial interest in the product or in a competing product.
  • Please be respectful in your tone.
  • Please do not submit any type of HTML markup or scripting as it will not be accepted.
Comment:

Add Comment...

Share your thoughts and comments about this topic in the space below. Please abide by the following rules:
  • If you make a statement of fact, such as whether a type of treatment does or does not work, state your basis -- such as personal experience or a published study.
  • If you make a positive or negative comment about a product, note whether or not you have a financial interest in the product or in a competing product.
  • Please be respectful in your tone.
  • Please do not submit any type of HTML markup or scripting as it will not be accepted.
Comment:

Edit Comment...

You can modify your comment below. Please be aware the comment will have to approve the changes before they will be shown:
Comment: