Initially Posted: 07/24/2015 | Last Updated: 03/06/2019
Menopause Supplements Tested by ConsumerLab.com -- Soy and Red Clover Isoflavones, Black Cohosh, and Progesterone Cream

Alphabetical list of menopause supplements and creams compared in this review

2775_large_Bluebonnet-Soy-Menopause-Large-2015.jpg

Bluebonnet Non-GMO Soy Isoflavones

4796_large_Emerita-Progesterone-Menopause-Large-2015.jpg

Emerita Progest Body Cream

2786_large_Estroven-Combination-Menopause-Large-2015.jpg

Estroven Maximum Strength

2781_large_NaturesBounty-BlackCohosh-Menopause-Large-2015.jpg

Nature's Bounty Black Cohosh

2782_large_NaturesWay-BlackCohosh-Large-2015.jpg

Nature's Way Black Cohosh Root

2774_large_Bayer-Soy-Menopause-Large-2015.jpg

One a Day Menopause Formula

2783_large_Oona-Combination-Menopause-Large-2015.jpg

Oona For Menopause

4800_large_Options-Soy-Menopause-Large-2015.jpg

Options Healthy Woman Soy Supplement

2779_large_Promensil-RedClover-Menopause-Large-2015.jpg

Promensil Menopause

Puritan's Pride Black Cohosh (540 mg root extract per softgel, 1 per day)

2784_large_Remifemin-BlackCohosh-Menopause-Large-2015.jpg

Remifemin Menopause Relief

2785_large_Rexall-BlackCohosh-Menopause-Large-2015.jpg

Rexall Black Cohosh

2787_large_Solgar-Combination-Menopause-Large-2015.jpg

Solgar Black Cohosh Root Extract Plus

4797_large_SourceNaturals-Progesterone-Menopause-Large-2015.jpg

Source Naturals Natural Progesterone Cream

2777_large_SpringValley-Soy-Menopause-Large-2015.jpg

Spring Valley (Walmart) Soy Isoflavones

2780_large_Swanson-RedClover-Menopause-Large-2015.jpg

Swanson Superior Herbs High-Potency Red Clover Extract

Vitamin World Black Cohosh

2778_large_WholeFoods-Soy-Menopause-Large-2015.jpg

Whole Foods Soy Isoflavones

Make sure the menopause supplement or cream you use passed our test and is right for you!
Isn't your health worth it?

See the Review Now

Join now at www.consumerlab.com/join/

Summary

  • Soy isoflavones have a mild estrogenic effect and can modestly reduce menopausal symptoms, such as hot flashes. Products providing at least 50 mg of soy isoflavones daily or of specific soy isoflavones (15 mg of genistein or 28 mg of daidzein) may be important for these effects and require treatment for several weeks before experiencing improvement. Higher doses are typically used to help maintain bone density (see Soy Isoflavones -- What It Does).
  • Product labeling typically does not provide details about the specific forms of isoflavones, but ConsumerLab determined these from testing, You can check amounts of isoflavones in products by looking at the 4th column of the Results Table below -- amounts known to be effective are in bold.
  • Be aware that only about 1/3 to ½ of women may benefit from isoflavones, depending on whether or not they convert isoflavones into active forms in their gut (See Soy Isoflavones —What It Is).
  • Red clover isoflavones may also have benefit in menopause, particularly in reducing night sweats, but it is recommended that products provide at least 40 mg daily of total isoflavones. Both products tested in this review provided this amount or more (See What CL Found).
  • Black cohosh, unlike soy isoflavones, does not have general estrogen-like actions, but may act like estrogen only in certain places, such as in the brain and the vaginal epithelium, providing no or modest benefit for symptoms such as hot flashes and vaginal dryness (See Black Cohosh —What It Does). The frequently recommended dosage of black cohosh is 20 mg of standardized extract once or twice a day, manufactured to contain at least 1 mg of triterpenes per day, although some products provide much larger amounts (See the 2nd and 4th columns in the Results Table below) and some products, like Remifemin, may work despite containing no triterpenes.
  • Progesterone cream may decrease menopausal hot flashes but does not provide enough progesterone to prevent bone loss or improve bone density (See Progesterone —What It Does). The progesterone creams tested by ConsumerLab were found to contain the amounts of progesterone they claimed. (See Progesterone Results Table).
You must join to get the full test results along with ConsumerLab.com recommendations and quality ratings to help you find the best menopause supplement for you. You will get results for 12 menopause supplements selected by ConsumerLab.com and for four others that passed voluntary Quality Certification Testing, as well as information about two supplements similar to ones that passed testing.  

In this comprehensive review, you'll discover:
  • Which menopausal products failed testing and which passed
  • Which soy or red clover supplements and progesterone creams provide amounts of ingredients shown to work 
  • Which foods provide large amounts of soy isoflavones
  • Potential side-effects with isoflavones, black cohosh, and progesterone cream

Join to unlock the full report and get full access to over 1,300 reviews

See the Review Now

Join now at www.consumerlab.com/join/