Initially Posted: 12/21/2018 | Expanded: 01/12/2020 | Last Updated: 09/18/2020
Protein, Meal, and Diet Powders, Shakes, and Drinks Tested by ConsumerLab.com

Alphabetical list of protein powder and protein drink brands compared in this review

6313_large_EAS-Whey-ProteinPowders-Large-2018.jpg

EAS 100% Whey Protein Chocolate

6323_large_AmazingGrass-Mixed-ProteinPowder-Large-2018.jpg

Amazing Grass Green Superfood

6325_large_BeachbodyPerformance-Mixed-ProteinPowder-Large-2018.jpg

Beachbody Performance Recover Post-Workout - Chocolate Flavored

6326_large_Beachbody-Shakeology-Chocolate-Mixed-ProteinPowder-Large-2018.jpg

Beachbody Shakeology - Chocolate

6327_large_Beachbody-Shakeology-Mixed-ProteinPowder-Large-2018.jpg

Beachbody Shakeology Vegan - Vanilla

6999_large_EntomoFarms-CricketPowder-ProteinPowders-Large-2020.jpg

ENTOMO Farms Cricket Powder

7000_large_Exo-CricketPowder-ProteinPowders-Large-2020.jpg

EXO Pure Cricket Powder

6328_large_GardenOfLife-Whey-ProteinPowders-Large-2018.jpg

Garden of Life RAW Organic Meal Vanilla

6329_large_GardenOfLife-GrassFed-Whey-Vanilla-Mixed-ProteinPowder-Large-2018.jpg

Garden of Life Sport Certified Grass Fed Whey - Vanilla

6330_large_GardenOfLife-Sport-Mixed-ProteinPowders-Large-2018.jpg

Garden of Life Sport Organic Plant-Based Protein - Vanilla

6314_large_GardenOfLife-OrganicWhey-Mixed-ProteinPowder-Large-2018.jpg

Garden of Life Organic Whey Protein Grass Fed

6337_large_GNC-AmplifiedWheybolic-Whey-ProteinPowders-Large-2019.jpg

GNC Amplified Wheybolic 40 - Chocolate

6338_large_GNC-TotalLeanShake-Whey-ProteinPowders-Large-2019.jpg

GNC Total Lean, Lean Shake 25 Swiss Chocolate

6315_large_MyProtein-Whey-ProteinPowders-Large-2018.jpg

MyProtein Impact Whey Isolate

6321_large_NOW-Pea-ProteinPowders-Large-2018.jpg

NOW Sports Pea Protein - Natural Unflavored

6322_large_Nutiva-Hemp-ProteinPowders-Large-2018.jpg

Nutiva Organic Hemp Protein Powder

6316_large_ON-Whey-ProteinPowders-Large-2018.jpg

ON [Optimum Nutrition] Gold Standard 100% Whey - Delicious Strawberry

6331_large_Orgain-Mixed-ProteinPowder-Large-2018.jpg

Orgain Organic Protein - Vanilla Bean

6320_large_PaleoThin-Egg-ProteinPowders-Large-2018.jpg

PaleoThin Organic Egg White Protein - Unflavored

6332_large_PlantFusion-Mixed-ProteinPowder-Large-2018.jpg

PlantFusion Complete Plant Protein - Vanilla Bean

6333_large_PremierProtein-Mixed-ProteinPowder-Large-2018.jpg

Premier Protein - Chocolate

6317_large_Protein2O-ProteinPowers--Whey-Drinks-Large-2018.jpg.jpg

Protein2O - Harvest Grape

6334_large_Quest-Mixed-ProteinPowder-Large-2018.jpg

Quest Protein Powder - Salted Caramel Flavor

6318_large_Universal-Milk-Casein-Large-2018.jpg

Universal Casein Pro - Vanilla Soft Serve

6335_large_Vega-Mixed-ProteinPowder-Large-2018.jpg

Vega Sport Performance Protein - Vanilla Flavor

6319_large_Vitacost-Soy-ProteinPowders-Large-2018.jpg

Vitacost Soy Protein Isolate - Natural Chocolate Flavor

Make sure your protein powder or protein drink passed our test and is right for you!
Isn't your health worth it?

See The Review Now

Join now at www.consumerlab.com/join/

Summary

  • Do they help? Extra protein (typically about 30 grams to 50 grams per day) from a powder or drink can help athletes build muscle, and help older people prevent or reverse age-related loss of muscle and strength when used in conjunction with resistance-type exercise. It may also help people with diabetes maintain blood sugar levels and even reverse diabetes if taken as part of low calorie diet. (See What It Does).
  • What type? Protein products vary based on the source of protein (e.g., whey, casein, soy, rice, pea, egg, hemp, and cricket). All can help build muscle, but, in general, whey is most popular as it is a complete protein and rather quickly digested. Casein is digested more slowly — which is why it is sometimes taken in the evening — to counter loss of muscle at night. Vegans may be more interested in plant sources, such soy, pea, rice, and hemp. See ConsumerTips, Protein for more about each type of protein.
  • Which brand? Among the protein products that ConsumerLab.com selected for review, 23.5% failed to pass tests. (See What CL Found). Among products that were Approved, the lowest cost to obtain an equivalent amount (20 grams) of protein was 37 cents from a pea protein powder while it was over $5 for some products with many additional ingredients or offering more of a meal-replacement profile. For most products, the cost to obtain 20 grams of protein fell within 80 cents to $1.50. See which products were CL's Top Picks based on a combination of quality, value, and taste. You can also compare all of the products in the Results Table.
  • How to use? Protein taken after, rather than before, exercise may be more beneficial (See What It Does). Protein powders are typically mixed with water or other liquids such as milk or juice, but be aware that these can add calories (See What to Consider When Using). Also be aware that taste of powders varies by protein type, flavorings, and the addition of sugar or other sweeteners, and that and some powders mix more easily into liquids than others (see the taste and mixability comments in the Results Table).
  • Cautions: Protein supplements may cause gastrointestinal discomfort in some people, and individuals with lactose intolerance may want to avoid certain milk-based proteins. People with kidney disease should consult with their physician before taking protein supplements (see Concerns and Cautions).
You must be a member to get the full test results, along with ConsumerLab's recommendations. You'll get results for 26 protein supplements -- 17 selected by ConsumerLab and nine that passed the same testing through our voluntary Quality Certification Program. 

In this comprehensive review, you'll discover:
  • Which protein products failed testing, which passed, and which are CL's Top Picks
  • How protein powders and drinks compare on taste, mixability, ingredients and price
  • The pros and cons of different types of protein (whey, casein, soy, rice, pea, egg, hemp, bone broth, and cricket) and different forms of protein (concentrates, isolates, and hydrolysates)
  • When to take protein for the best results
  • Ingredients you may want to avoid in protein powders and drinks

Join to unlock the full report and get full access to over 1,300 reviews

See The Review Now

Join now at www.consumerlab.com/join/