ConsumerLab.com uses JavaScript to provide the best possible experience for our content, but your browser has it disabled. Learn how to enable it here.

About ConsumerLab.com

Last Updated: 11/13/2020 |
Meal Replacement Supplements Reviewed by ConsumerLab.com

Meal replacement and weight management powders and beverages compared in this review

5224_small_Atkins-MealReplacement-Small-2016.jpg

Atkins Day Break - Strawberry Banana Shake

5232_small_FitMiss-MealReplacement-Small-2016.jpg

FitMiss Delight Chocolate Delight

5230_small_GardenOfLife-MealReplacement-Small-2016.jpg

Garden of Life RAW Organic Meal Vanilla

5227_small_Herbalife-MealReplacement-Small-2016.jpg

Herbalife Formula 1 Healthy Meal French Vanilla

5233_small_IsAgenix-MealReplacement-Small-2016-v2.jpg.jpg

IsAgenix IsaLean Shake Natural Berry Harvest

5225_small_JarrowFormulas-MealReplacement-Small-2016.jpg

Jarrow Formulas The Slim Whey Green Tea

5231_small_Metagenics-MealReplacement-Small-2016.jpg

Metagenics UltraMeal Rice Vanilla

5228_small_Naturade-MealReplacement-Small-2016.jpg

Naturade Total Soy Chocolate

5234_small_NaturesPlus-SpiruTein-Small-2016.jpg

Nature's Plus Spiru-Tein Powder Vanilla Soy

5226_small_SlimFast-MealReplacement-Small-2016.jpg

SlimFast Advanced Nutrition Creamy Chocolate

5229_small_Soylent-MealReplacement-Small-2016-v2.jpg.jpg

Soylent

5235_small_SpecialK-MealReplacement-Small-2016.jpg

Special K Protein Vanilla Cappuccino

5236_small_VegaOne-MealReplacement-Small-2016.jpg

Vega One All-In-One Nutritional Shake French Vanilla

Make sure the meal replacement or weight management product you takeĀ passed our tests!
Isn't your health worth it?

See the Review Now

Join now at www.consumerlab.com/join/

Summary

  • Do meal replacement powders and shakes help? Meal replacement shakes -- ready-to-drink or made from a powder, have been shown to help people on diets lose more weight, improve blood sugar control for people with type 2 diabetes, and boost protein intake to increase muscle mass. It can also offer a more healthful alternative to snack foods when you are unable to have a regular meal. In particular, meal replacements offer protein in a convenient form, along with carbohydrates (and often fiber) as well as fats. The products, however, are not meant to replace all of your meals and consumption of whole foods, such as fruits and vegetables. (See "What It Does").
  • What's in meal replacement shakes? Most products provide about 10 to 20 grams of protein (from a variety of sources) per serving but vary widely in the amounts and types of carbohydrates and fats they include. They may also have a range of vitamins, minerals, and botanical ingredients. Serving sizes also range widely, from about 25 to 60 grams providing about 90 to 400 Calories. (See "Comparison Chart").
  • Which meal replacement powders and shakes are best? ConsumerLab.com found that 4 of the 11 meal replacement products it selected and tested were not accurately labeled and/or had an unacceptable contamination (See "What CL Found"). Among those which were Approved based on their quality, CL then compared the products on features such as protein, energy, fiber and cost and made its Top Picks. You can compare specifics of the products using the Results Table.
  • How to use meal replacement shakes? Products sold as powders are typically mixed with water or other liquids, but be aware of what you are adding (calories, carbs, etc.). (See ConsumerTipsā„¢).
  • Cautions with meal replacement shakes: Do not substitute a meal replacement product for all of your meals or be fooled into thinking that you can skip eating whole foods. In addition, be aware that you may need to increase your fluid and calcium intake if you are increasing your protein intake. (See Concerns and Cautions).

You must be a member to get the full test results for meal replacement supplements along with ConsumerLab.com recommendations and quality ratings. In this comprehensive review, you'll get test results for 13 products, including two which passed ConsumerLab.com's voluntary Quality Certification Program. You'll discover:
  • Which powders and shakes failed testing and which passed, earning top quality ratings -- and why
  • ConsumerLab.com's Top Picks
  • Head-to-head comparisons of the protein, fats, and carbohydrates (including sugar and fiber) in all meal replacement products reviewed and rated
  • Nutritional intake recommendations
  • Clinical evidence regarding the use of meal replacements for weight loss, blood sugar control, and muscle gain
  • Concerns and cautions with using meal replacement products

Also see ConsumerLab.com's Protein Powders & Shakes Review.

Join to unlock the full report and get full access to over 1,300 reviews

See the Review Now

Join now at www.consumerlab.com/join/