1. Home
  2. / Product Reviews
  3. / Dark Chocolate

Dark Chocolates, Cocoa & Cacao Powders, Nibs, and Supplements Review -- Sources of Flavanols

Find the Best Dark Chocolate, Cocoa Powder and Cocoa Supplements. Is Your Chocolate or Cocoa Healthful or Toxic? Find Out Now!

Reviewed and edited by Tod Cooperman, M.D. cooperman.png

Initially Posted: 12/20/2019 | Last Updated: 09/12/2020
Flavanols in Cocoa, Cacoa, and Chocolate Products Reviewed by ConsumerLab.com

Alphabetical list of cocoa, cacao, and dark chocolate products compared in this review

6937_large_AlterEco-Cocoa-2019-19.png

Alter Eco Deep Dark Blackout

6938_large_Bakers-Cocoa-2019-17.png

Baker's Semi-Sweet Baking Chocolate Bar

6939_large_BakersUnsweeteed-Cocoa-2019-19.png

Baker's Unsweetened - 100% Cacao

6940_large_Chocolove-Cocoa-2019-17.png

Chocolove Extra Strong - 77% Cocoa Content

6941_large_Chocolove-Strong-Cocoa-2019-19.png

Chocolove Strong Dark Chocolate - 70% Cocoa Content

6971_large_CocoVia-Cocoa-2019-19.png

CocoaVia

6995_large_CocoaVia-CranRaspberry-Cocoa-2020.png

CocoaVia - Cran-Raspberry (Mix)

6996_large_CocoaVia-Original-Cocoa-2020.png

CocoaVia - Original (Mix)

6997_large_CocoaVia-SweetenedDarkChocolate-Cocoa-2020.png

CocoaVia - Sweetened Dark Chocolate Mix

6970_large_CocoaVia-Unsweetened-Cocoa-2019-19.png

CocoaVia - Unsweetened Dark Chocolate Mix

6958_large_Dagoba-Cacao-2019-17.png

Dagoba Organic Chocolate Cacao Powder

6942_large_Dove-Cocoa-2019-17.png

Dove Dark Chocolate

6943_large_EndangeredSpecies-Cocoa-2019-19.png

Endangered Species Chocolate Strong + Velvety Dark Chocolate - 88% Cocoa

6944_large_EqualExchange-Cocoa-2019-17.png

Equal Exchange Chocolates Organic Panama Extra Dark - 80% Cacao

6973_large_FutureBiotics-Cocoa-2019-17.png

Futurebiotics Dark Chocolate Extract

6956_large_Ghirardelli-Cocoa-2019-19.png

Ghirardelli Chocolate Premium Baking Chips - 60% Cacao Bittersweet Chocolate

6959_large_Ghirardelli-100-Cocoa-2019-19.png

Ghirardelli Chocolate Premium Baking Cocoa - 100% Cocoa

6945_large_Ghirardelli-86-Cocoa-2019-17.png

Ghirardelli Intense Dark 86% Cacao

6957_large_Guittard-Cocoa-2019-19.png

Guittard Extra Dark Chocolate Baking Chips - 63% Cacao

6974_large_HawaiiPharm-Cocoa-2019-17.png

Hawaii Pharm Cacao

6967_large_Healthworks-Cocoa-2019-19.png

Healthworks Cacao Nibs

6960_large_Healthworks-CacaoPowder-Cocoa-2019-17.png

Healthworks Cacao Powder

6976_large_Hersheys-Natural-Cocoa-2019-17 (1).png

Hershey's Cocoa - 100% Cacao Natural Unsweetened

6961_large_Hersheys-Dutched-Cocoa-2019-19 (1).png

Hershey's Cocoa Special Dark - 100% Cacao

6946_large_Lilys-Cocoa-2019-17 (1).png

Lily's Dark Chocolate - Original - Stevia Sweetened

6947_large_Lindt-Cocoa-2019-19 (1).png

Lindt Excellence Supreme Dark - 90% Cocoa

6948_large_Montezumas-Cocoa-2019-19 (1).png

Montezuma's Dark Chocolate Absolute Black - 100% Cocoa

6949_large_MoserRoth-Cocoa-2019-17 (1).png

Moser Roth Edel Bitter 85% Cacao

6977_large_Navitas-Powder-2019-19.png

Navitas Naturals Cacao Powder

6968_large_Navitas-Nibs-Cocoa-2019-19.png

Navitas Organics Organic Cacao Nibs

6950_large_Pascha-Cocoa-2019-17.png

Pascha Organic Dark Chocolate - 85% Cacao

6951_large_ScharffenBerger-Cocoa-2019-19 (1).png

Scharffen Berger Unsweetened - 99% Cacao

6975_large_Solaray-Cocoa-2019-17.png

Solaray Cocoa

6952_large_TazaChocolate-Cocoa-2019-19 (1).png

Taza Chocolate Wicked Dark - 95% Dark

6953_large_Theo-Cocoa-2019-19 (1).png

Theo Sea Salt - 70% Dark Chocolate

6963_large_TraderJoes-Powder-Cocoa-2019-17 (1).png

Trader Joe's Cocoa Powder Unsweetened

6955_large_TraderJoes-Cocoa-2019-17 (1).png

Trader Joe's The Dark Chocolate Lover's Chocolate Bar - 85% Cacao

6964_large_TraderJoes-Powder-Cocoa-2019-19 (1).png

Trader Joe's Organic Fair Trade Cacao Powder

6954_large_TraderJoes-PoundPlus-Cocoa-2019-19.png

Trader Joe's Pound Plus - 72% Cacao Dark Chocolate

6965_large_Valrhona-Cocoa-2019-19 (1).png

Valrhona Poudre De Cacao Cocoa Powder - 100% Cacao

6969_large_VivaNaturals-Cocoa-2019-17 (1).png

Viva Naturals Cacao Nibs Organic

6966_large_Volupta-Cocoa-2019-19 (1).png

Volupta Cacao Powder

Make sure the cocoa, cacao, or chocolate you use passed our tests and is right for you!
Isn't your health worth it?

See The Review Now

Join now at www.consumerlab.com/join/

Summary

  • What are the health benefits? Cocoa-based products contain flavanols which are associated with modest potential benefits regarding blood flow, blood pressure, cholesterol levels, exercise, memory/cognition, skin wrinkles, and blood sugar control (see What It Does).
  • Which product is best? Be careful! Our tests show that many popular cocoa powders and cacao nibs, as well as some dark chocolates, are contaminated with high levels of cadmium, a toxic heavy metal (see What CL Found). Fortunately, we were able to identify a few great products that minimize cadmium exposure, maximize flavanols, offer superior value, and even minimize calories without sacrificing flavor. See CL's Top Picks.
  • How much do I need? Clinical studies suggest the following total daily intakes of flavanols for the purposes noted below, although further research is needed to confirm benefits and optimal dosing: To get these amounts look at the 3rd column in the Results Table below. It will show you the amount of flavanols in a serving of each product.
  • Is it safe? Although cocoa and chocolate products are generally safe, it may be best to limit consumption of products due to contaminants, as well as calories (See How much of a danger is cadmium and lead from cocoa and chocolate?) Be aware that the caffeine and theobromine in cocoa products may cause side effects as well as interfere with the actions of certain drugs. Cocoa and chocolate products may also trigger migraines in some people and may trigger allergic contact dermatitis in nickel-sensitive individuals. People with milk allergies should be aware that dark chocolate bars may contain milk (see Concerns and Cautions).
You must be a ConsumerLab.com member to get the full test results along with ConsumerLab.com's Top Picks among products. You'll get immediate access to the amounts of flavanols and cadmium that we discovered in 42 dark chocolate bars and chips, cocoa powders, cacao nibs, and cocoa supplements, including 37 selected by ConsumerLab.com and five products tested through our voluntary Quality Certification Program. If you are sensitive to caffeine or theobromine, you'll also want to see how much we found in each dark chocolate bar and supplement — something not typically listed on labels. In this comprehensive review, you'll discover:
  • Which cocoa, cacao, and dark chocolate products failed testing and which passed
  • ConsumerLab.com's Top Picks among the best cocoa and dark chocolate products
  • Direct comparisons and quality ratings of cocoa, cacao, and chocolate products
  • Cost comparisons, showing you which cocoa, cacao, and chocolate products provide the most flavanols at lowest cost
  • Dosage information for using cocoa-based products -- and what clinical studies have shown
  • Side-effects, cautions, and potential drug interactions with cocoa and dark chocolate, including concerns about allergies, acne, acrylamide, migraine, ochratoxin A, blood sugar control, and kidney stones

Join to unlock the full report and get full access to over 1,300 reviews

See The Review Now

Join now at www.consumerlab.com/join/

Related CL Answers (26)

Do any supplements help prevent sunburn or skin damage from sun exposure?

Find out which supplements may help protect from sunburn and sun-related skin damage, including beta-carotene, vitamins A and C, and cocoa. ConsumerLab's answer explains.

How much cocoa or chocolate do I need to consume in order to get a benefit?

Learn more eating chocolate and cocoa including the benefits, amounts and info on studies. ConsumerLab's answer explains.

Why does dark chocolate have iron in it? Is it, or cocoa, a good dietary source of iron?

Find out if dark chocolate or cocoa is a good source of iron and if iron from dark chocolate or cocoa can be well-absorbed. ConsumerLab's answer explains.

Which dark chocolate bar has the most flavanols with the least calories?

Find out which dark chocolates are lowest in calories and contain the most flavanols, according to our lab tests. ConsumerLab's answer explains.

Why is there so much cadmium, a toxin, in cocoa powders but not in dark chocolate?

Learn more about the presence of the toxic heavy metal cadmium in cocoa powder and dark chocolate. ConsumerLab's answer explains.

I heard somewhere to avoid chocolate with "processed with alkali" in the ingredients. Is that true?

Learn more about cocoa processed with alkali ("dutched") and its effect on flavanols. ConsumerLab's answer explains.

How much fat is there in chocolate? Is it saturated fat?

Learn more about the fat content in dark chocolate & milk chocolate, how much is saturated, and serving size. ConsumerLab's answer explains.

How much caffeine is really in dark chocolate bars?

Just how much caffeine is really in chocolate bars? Get our test results on the caffeine content in dark chocolate and cocoa powder. ConsumerLab's answer explains.

Does chocolate really cause migraines?

Find out if there is a link between chocolate/cocoa and migraines. ConsumerLab's answer explains.

Which supplements can help me sleep?

Find out which supplements may improve sleep, including melatonin, L-tryptophan, and magnesium, and which may make sleeping more difficult. ConsumerLab's answer explains.

Which supplements can help with indigestion and/or heartburn?

Information on supplements for heartburn that can help relieve gastrointestinal symptoms - heartburn, indigestion and acid reflux. ConsumerLab's answer explains.

Can chocolate and cocoa powder cause eczema?

Does chocolate and cocoa cause eczema? Find out more, including information about nickel and nickel allergies. ConsumerLab's answer explains.

Which supplements can help to lower blood pressure?

Supplements to lower blood pressure, including CoQ10, vitamin C, fish oil, and olive oil, are all explored to find out what works. ConsumerLab's answer explains.

Are cocoa and chocolate products contaminated with the fungal toxin ochratoxin A?

Learn more about toxins associated with cocoa beans and if chocolate contains contaminants like ochratoxin A (OTA). ConsumerLab's answer explains.

How much dark chocolate equals a tablespoon of cocoa powder?

Learn how much dark chocolate will give you the same intake of flavanols as a tablespoon of cocoa powder. ConsumerLab's answer explains.

Which supplements help to improve energy and decrease fatigue?

Energy supplements and vitamins - Some can help increase energy and reduce fatigue, including CoQ10, curcumin/turmeric, cocoa, and B vitamins. ConsumerLab's answer explains.

Is the theobromine in chocolate and cocoa good or bad for me?

Find out the benefits and risks of theobromine -- and how much is in dark chocolate. ConsumerLab's answer explains.

Does CoQ10 reduce wrinkles, increase skin elasticity, or tighten the skin? Are there any other supplements that can help?

Learn about CoQ10 and other supplements, such as collagen and cocoa, for reducing wrinkles and improve aging skin. ConsumerLab's answer explains.

Is Hershey's Special Dark better than other dark chocolate bars or cocoa powders?

Find out if Hershey's Special Dark Chocolate bar is better than other dark chocolate bars or cocoa powders, including flavanol content, contamination with lead or cadmium and other tests of quality. ConsumerLab.com's answer explains.

What is acrylamide? Is it true that coffee and cocoa contain this toxin?

Find out what acrylamide is, how much is found in coffee and cocoa, and how you can minimize your intake of acrylamide.

What are the health benefits of dark chocolate?

Information on the health benefits of dark chocolate, including how dark chocolate may improve heart health, decrease blood sugar levels and more. ConsumerLab.com's answer explains.

The distributor of my cacao powder says it checks for "metal fragments" in its products. Is this adequate to check for heavy metals, like cadmium and lead, that you've found in cocoas and chocolates?

Find out if tests such as foreign metal detection can show if cocoa powders and chocolate products are contaminated with heavy metals such as cadmium and lead. See amounts of these toxic heavy metals were found in cocoa and chocolate products tested by ConsumerLab.com

What is the difference between cocoa and cacao? Is one better than the other?

Learn about the difference between cocoa vs. cacao, including cocoa powder, cocoa extracts, cocoa liquor, and cacao nibs. Information about benefits, caffeine, theobromine in cocoa and cacoa, differences between dark chocolate and milk chocolate. ConsumerLab.com's answer explains.

Can cocoa and chocolate cause kidney stones?

Find out if cocoa and chocolate can cause kidney stones, such as calcium oxalate kidney stones, the amount of oxalates found in cocoa powders and chocolate bars, and more. ConsumerLab.com's answer explains.

Which dietary supplements and health foods contain high levels of lead?

Information about lead and heavy metals in vitamins, supplements and foods. Information on the adverse effects of lead. ConsumerLab's answer explains.

Which vitamins and supplements are good for acne, and are there any that make it worse?

Information about supplements for acne and clearer skin. Plus, find out which vitamins and supplements can make acne worse. ConsumerLab's answer explains.

As a ConsumerLab.com member, you may print a copy of this report for your personal use.

You can access a special print version by clicking the "Print" icon in the upper right corner of this report. You can then use your web browser's print functions to print the whole report or just selected pages.

You may also email or post a link to this report using the web address above. Non-members using the link will see a free summary and can join to view the full report. Other means of copying or distributing this report, in part or full, are not permitted.

If you are sight-impaired and your computer is having trouble converting the text in this report to speech, contact us for assistance at Membership@ConsumerLab.com or by phone at 914-722-9149.